Thursday, November 17, 2011

Why the Excluded Middle?

The title comes from Lotfi Zadeh, an extraordinary engineering professor at UC Berkeley who is the creator of the field of fuzzy logic.  Lotfi, who has forgotten more math than most of engineers will ever know, was looking at complex problems that were not addressed by conventional means, where methods either took binary logic (yes or no) or some sort of esoteric impractical method.  In creating fuzzy logic, he was trying to find a way to access "the excluded middle" between the pure yes and pure no, where practical solutions might actually exist.  Now, I am a veteran of what I call the "Fuzzy Logic Wars" where proponents of this methodology claimed all sorts of magical properties that would make Albus DumbleDore scream, "You're freakin' kidding me, right?"  This doesn't mean that the concept doesn't have validity.  Just that it was overplayed.

The excluded middle opens up whenever folks decide that ideology is more important than what works.

As an engineer by training, I have grown into being an engineer in mind and heart.  Engineers look for practical solutions to real problems, not perfect ideology.    When I see a lot of rantings about this and that, I see some sort of push for perfect ideology, that one statement can encompass the universe.  This is BS, pure and simple.  I have learned that very few practical systems in engineering are at an extreme.  Instead, we engineers push for excellence but leave ourselves margins for the stuff we can't control or predict, because we know there will always be some of that. 

So, while many mathematicians look for the optimum, ideal, or perfect solution, (as do some engineers who fancy themselves mathematicians), engineers in the real world look for practical simple stuff that is hard to bust.  We live for "the excluded middle", and that is where I believe a lot of life's solutions exist. 

Optimality sucks, but excellence rocks.  This is what I will talk about.