Okay, I'm an engineer, a gearhead, a nerd. Glad we got that over with.
Now, one of the things that engineers can't stand is mathematics that you can't do anything with. We learn a lot of math, but when the stuff is just esoteric and we can't use it, it pisses us off (technical term). We do like math that allows us to do stuff, to build things, understand nature, fix things.
To that end, we learn to love an idealization of math known as the linear, time-invariant system. The idea is that a lot of things can be modeled using math. Things that move are often modeled using what is known as differential equations, where the change in the behavior of something is a function of where it is. Now, a lot of this is complicated and hard to solve, but when that function is linear and doesn't change over time, it opens up a lot of nice tools to us. Like protomatter for Captain Kirk's son, David Marcus, it solves a lot of problems. So, we tend to try to beat a lot of problems into areas where we can whip out our linear, time-invariant system tools.
Here's the thing: those are idealizations. Nature isn't really that way in any detail, but we can get a lot of things done if we assume that it is. Engineers that work in the real world are very cautious about this, though, because real world stuff tends to break those assumptions. We know that friction, and grease, and wind, and crap (that isn't modeled by our linear, time-invariant math) is in our real system.
So, why bring this all up? Because a lot of the rhetoric that we hear is based on similar idealizations of nature and human behavior. Folks tell you that all we need to do is cut taxes or rich people or give every slacker the same level of living as every hard worker, and everything will be fine. And they would be if those people and the world were linear and time-invariant. But they aren't.
People are definitely nonlinear and they do vary a lot over time. So any idealized model of human behavior is BS. There is always friction.
The Excluded Middle
Sunday, March 11, 2012
Saturday, March 10, 2012
Is greed good or bad? Yes.
Gordon Gecko, the movie foreshadowing of Mitt Romney, once captivated an audience with the simple statement, "Greed is good." The premise was that being greedy clarified what you needed to do and as long as everyone was greedy at the same time, something better would be achieved. In the end, of course, Gecko is exposed for cheating to get to his greedy goals, and sent to prison for it.
In the modern parlance, former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney, who made a fortune buying out corporations and then selling off their parts, defines what he did as "capitalism", much as Tony Soprano and Michael Corleone define what they are doing as "business." And yet, Bill Hewlett and Dave Packard, the Varian brothers, Steve Jobs, and a host of other innovators made the world better while making fortunes. None of these guys was Gandhi or Mother Teresa in the slightest way, and yet nobody saw their desire to make money, their greed, as cheating or bad.
(At this point I will digress to tip my hat to anyone who ever worked directly for Steve Jobs. Several friends of mine have and while they are quick to acknowledge his genius at understanding what consumers would buy, not a one of them considered interaction with him a pleasant experience. And I don't think any of the kids in those factories making iPODs would think he is a nice guy. Yet, the world thinks of him as a great contributor. Arrogant? Yes. Genius? Probably. Nice guy? Nope. Contributor to society? Definitely. Greedy? Yup.)
I guess my point is that greed on its own is a very broad term. The desire to make a lot of money and to have a lot of stuff is not necessarily evil, as shown by contributors to society that made lots of money for their contributions. The Wright Brothers, Glen Curtis, Henry Ford, Thomas Watson, Hewlett and Packard, all got into their business to make money. All made contributions that made the world better while making tons of money. Some of these folks were anything but saints. By the same token, making lots of money doesn't mean that you contributed to society. One can make a lot of money as an assassin. Making tons of money only means that you were able to produce something that folks are willing to pay for. That might be a life saving medicine or it might be heroin.
All over Silicon Valley, and all over the world, people start businesses. Most care about how they make money, but they are all doing it to make money. It's fundamental. People want to be rewarded for doing something right. You make take the Zen/Gandhi/Christ like view that you shouldn't need any outward reward, but folks have to eat, pay the rent/mortgage, send their kids to school, etc. and so people want to be rewarded. Communism is based on the wonderfully idealistic view that people will work to their maximum for the group despite the fact that the person next to them is working only half as hard. It is a wonderful notion, but it doesn't line up with any real people I have ever met. I couldn't and wouldn't sustain maximum effort for someone who was slacking off. I'm not sure why anyone else would. So, if you want folks to do great things, generally there is at least the possibility of some great reward, be that money, fame, love, respect, whatever.
In one of the times when folks took Charlie Sheen seriously, he screams at Gordon Gecko, "How many yachts can you ski behind?" How much is enough? How much is too much? The question as to whether greed is good or bad maybe should be rephrased as, "How much greed is good?" and "What kind of greed is good?"
Shouldn't it matter how we make money, rather than just how much we made? If we pull a good profit by doing something that makes the world better, maybe our greed is good. If the money becomes the only metric against we are measured, then we are no better than Tony Soprano or Michael Corleone doing "business" and what we call "capitalism" is simply making money with no regard for anything or anyone else.
In the modern parlance, former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney, who made a fortune buying out corporations and then selling off their parts, defines what he did as "capitalism", much as Tony Soprano and Michael Corleone define what they are doing as "business." And yet, Bill Hewlett and Dave Packard, the Varian brothers, Steve Jobs, and a host of other innovators made the world better while making fortunes. None of these guys was Gandhi or Mother Teresa in the slightest way, and yet nobody saw their desire to make money, their greed, as cheating or bad.
(At this point I will digress to tip my hat to anyone who ever worked directly for Steve Jobs. Several friends of mine have and while they are quick to acknowledge his genius at understanding what consumers would buy, not a one of them considered interaction with him a pleasant experience. And I don't think any of the kids in those factories making iPODs would think he is a nice guy. Yet, the world thinks of him as a great contributor. Arrogant? Yes. Genius? Probably. Nice guy? Nope. Contributor to society? Definitely. Greedy? Yup.)
I guess my point is that greed on its own is a very broad term. The desire to make a lot of money and to have a lot of stuff is not necessarily evil, as shown by contributors to society that made lots of money for their contributions. The Wright Brothers, Glen Curtis, Henry Ford, Thomas Watson, Hewlett and Packard, all got into their business to make money. All made contributions that made the world better while making tons of money. Some of these folks were anything but saints. By the same token, making lots of money doesn't mean that you contributed to society. One can make a lot of money as an assassin. Making tons of money only means that you were able to produce something that folks are willing to pay for. That might be a life saving medicine or it might be heroin.
All over Silicon Valley, and all over the world, people start businesses. Most care about how they make money, but they are all doing it to make money. It's fundamental. People want to be rewarded for doing something right. You make take the Zen/Gandhi/Christ like view that you shouldn't need any outward reward, but folks have to eat, pay the rent/mortgage, send their kids to school, etc. and so people want to be rewarded. Communism is based on the wonderfully idealistic view that people will work to their maximum for the group despite the fact that the person next to them is working only half as hard. It is a wonderful notion, but it doesn't line up with any real people I have ever met. I couldn't and wouldn't sustain maximum effort for someone who was slacking off. I'm not sure why anyone else would. So, if you want folks to do great things, generally there is at least the possibility of some great reward, be that money, fame, love, respect, whatever.
In one of the times when folks took Charlie Sheen seriously, he screams at Gordon Gecko, "How many yachts can you ski behind?" How much is enough? How much is too much? The question as to whether greed is good or bad maybe should be rephrased as, "How much greed is good?" and "What kind of greed is good?"
Shouldn't it matter how we make money, rather than just how much we made? If we pull a good profit by doing something that makes the world better, maybe our greed is good. If the money becomes the only metric against we are measured, then we are no better than Tony Soprano or Michael Corleone doing "business" and what we call "capitalism" is simply making money with no regard for anything or anyone else.
Thursday, November 17, 2011
Why the Excluded Middle?
The title comes from Lotfi Zadeh, an extraordinary engineering professor at UC Berkeley who is the creator of the field of fuzzy logic. Lotfi, who has forgotten more math than most of engineers will ever know, was looking at complex problems that were not addressed by conventional means, where methods either took binary logic (yes or no) or some sort of esoteric impractical method. In creating fuzzy logic, he was trying to find a way to access "the excluded middle" between the pure yes and pure no, where practical solutions might actually exist. Now, I am a veteran of what I call the "Fuzzy Logic Wars" where proponents of this methodology claimed all sorts of magical properties that would make Albus DumbleDore scream, "You're freakin' kidding me, right?" This doesn't mean that the concept doesn't have validity. Just that it was overplayed.
The excluded middle opens up whenever folks decide that ideology is more important than what works.
As an engineer by training, I have grown into being an engineer in mind and heart. Engineers look for practical solutions to real problems, not perfect ideology. When I see a lot of rantings about this and that, I see some sort of push for perfect ideology, that one statement can encompass the universe. This is BS, pure and simple. I have learned that very few practical systems in engineering are at an extreme. Instead, we engineers push for excellence but leave ourselves margins for the stuff we can't control or predict, because we know there will always be some of that.
So, while many mathematicians look for the optimum, ideal, or perfect solution, (as do some engineers who fancy themselves mathematicians), engineers in the real world look for practical simple stuff that is hard to bust. We live for "the excluded middle", and that is where I believe a lot of life's solutions exist.
Optimality sucks, but excellence rocks. This is what I will talk about.
The excluded middle opens up whenever folks decide that ideology is more important than what works.
As an engineer by training, I have grown into being an engineer in mind and heart. Engineers look for practical solutions to real problems, not perfect ideology. When I see a lot of rantings about this and that, I see some sort of push for perfect ideology, that one statement can encompass the universe. This is BS, pure and simple. I have learned that very few practical systems in engineering are at an extreme. Instead, we engineers push for excellence but leave ourselves margins for the stuff we can't control or predict, because we know there will always be some of that.
So, while many mathematicians look for the optimum, ideal, or perfect solution, (as do some engineers who fancy themselves mathematicians), engineers in the real world look for practical simple stuff that is hard to bust. We live for "the excluded middle", and that is where I believe a lot of life's solutions exist.
Optimality sucks, but excellence rocks. This is what I will talk about.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)